The case of my copy of Wizardry I/II is seriously cracked. I had never really noticed it before, but the case is fatter than a standard jewel case, making it hard to replace.
The only other fat cases I have in my collection are the Ziria re-issue (with the red toad on the cover), Arunamu の Kiba, and the ArcadePRO card's case.
Which games came in such a "fattie"? Maybe I can find a cheap replacement online, if a lesser-loved (and cheaper to buy) game shipped like that.