What about the Hori sticks? I have purchased 2 of them (waiting for the mailman) and I'm not sure if the money is well spend?
Best stick you can buy for the PCE. Congrats on finding a pair.. they're extremely hard to find.
No way man. The Sigma sticks are far superior...but much much harder to find. I think probably only a couple hundred were made, if that.
As for shooters though, I just use a regular CG pad. The action on the d-pad of stock PCE controllers is really nice, IMO, and since almost all of them have turbo fire, I'm not sure how they could be much more comfortable. If you are cramping or whatever, you just need to learn how to relax. If you can't relax, build a real Japan-style arcade stick. An arcade stick is better for comfort because control pads really can only be held properly one way, but a big ass arcade stick can be held whatever way you want.