Well Dan, from my understanding, the data written on cdrs is generally at a different distance from the lense than on pressed cds. Most lenses can move to compensate, but some (usually older ones) are unable to adjust. Since most people are able to play CDRs, i would assume that a new lense would fix it. The data on CDRs is also generally not as "crisp" as pressed ones, so a lense in less than optimal shape would have trouble with it for that reason as well.