Long story short: My buddy has a Duo and has had no issues with it. I offered to recap it because we all know whether they work or not, at this point they should be recapped. I reiterate, until I touched the thing everything worked properly.
I ordered a kit from Console 5 and recapped it today. Thankfully though there were several leaky caps there was no board damage. No pads lifted or anything. It was about the smoothest recapping I've done (which up to this point has only been Game Gears and my Laser Active Sega Pack).
Hooked it up and threw a card in it, everything was kosher. Popped a CD in it, extremely low audio. Checked the caps that I believe have to do with audio (C604, C610, C325, C323, C613, C614). They were all the correct values and polarity (according to C5's list and guide) and soldered tight. I even took them off and put them back on to be sure. I checked the C615, 306, and 305 as well. Everything seems to be proper.
Is it possible to have a bad new cap? What else should I be checking to trouble shoot?