Does the US Gate of Thunder suffer from having other games on the CD?

[Chuplayer]

Is there a tradeoff in the amount of music they could put on the CD compared to the Japanese version so they could fit the other three games? I'd hate to get the US version of Gate of Thunder just to find that music tracks are truncated. I'd rather have all of the music than the other three games.

(This is assuming the Japanese version doesn't have the same bonus games that would shorten its music tracks, too.)

[SignOfZeta]

Heh, no. Those games would take up about...I'm guess less than a minute of CD audio anyway. Someone with a calculator can do the actual math.

[Chuplayer]

I figured, but I just wanted to make sure. Even if there's one song that ended up getting shortened by as little as two seconds, I'd rather get the Japanese version.

[Tatsujin]

Heh, no. Those games would take up about...I'm guess less than a minute of CD audio anyway. Someone with a calculator can do the actual math.

I would say not more than few secs.

[Edmond Dantes]

Don't underestimate the storage capacity of CDs.  I doubt that Gate of Thunder uses the entire disc even with all the audio.

[nodtveidt]

CDROM games rarely use the entire disc space for music. GoT did not suffer data loss due to having additional games on the disc.

[sheath]

I think the rest of the games would only take up 1MB or so, but the intro menu with the pre-rendered scaling is probably relatively large.  I wouldn't know if anything was changed from the Japanese version though.

[Chuplayer]

CDROM games rarely use the entire disc space for music. GoT did not suffer data loss due to having additional games on the disc.

I've got some music CDs that take up nearly the entire space of the CD. I don't know how much music Gate of Thunder has, but if it's so much music that something would have to get cut, then I'd want to know.

[TheOldMan]

Let's assume they are HuCard games, converted to run from CD.
Max Hucard size is 8Mbit = 1Mbyte = 1024K.
Each CD sector is 2K, so each game takes up 512 sectors
At 75 sectors per second, that's about 7 sec per game.

Yeah, I don't think there is anything missing Much more likely is that they had all this space, and decided to throw some freebies in to use some of it. Or maybe the dev system was being shared

[Chuplayer]

21 seconds of missing music means enough to me to make me get the Japanese version. I'm not interested in speculation. I already speculated in my head, and my speculations led me here to ask for a confirmation.

"It's probably not a concern, don't underestimate the storage capacity of a CD" isn't what I'm looking for.

[SignOfZeta]

You are assuming that the original GoT was packed to the last second with every single byte of CD audio. I'm pretty sure this isn't the case with any PC Engine game. Most of them have 5-10 minutes of free space, sometimes twice that.

If they actually ran into space issues (which I highly highly doubt) they could just shorten the track 1 warning.

If you want the PCE version, by all means just get it. It has a much cooler case, which to me is far more important than 7 seconds of missing music. Most (all?) the stage music tracks are longer than the stages anyway so you'd never know it was truncated without listening to the game in an audio CD player, and if you are the kind of super fan that does that sort of thing it seems like you'd have both versions eventually.

[ccovell]

Here's your confirmation:

[Chuplayer]

SignOfZeta, I never assumed that.

ccovell, that is mega excellent! Thank you!

[Bonknuts]

I never even thought about it. I just assumed they were the same (nothing missing or shortened). Good to have confirmation though.

[Tatsujin]

Lol, if they really were running out of space,  they just would had shortened the ugha bonk intro, which probably alone takes about a multiple space of the three extra games on the disc.