My Secret Santa is from Ohio...
Okay, I did some snooping with the Search function and I know for sure that Arkhan is from Ohio, and I think also Rover. The gifts were wrapped pretty carefully, and Arkhan is all crazy, what with all the zany ALL CAPS TYPING and speaking in foreign tongues, so that doesn't seem his style. But then again, maybe he's secretly a gentle and tender soul who wraps presents all careful-like while sipping Chamomile tea.
Or maybe it's Rover. I sent him a raffle item once, I think... (checking my e-mails and PMs now...)... Nope that's not it.
Okay, checked the address and it's near Cleveland, so I'm gonna say it's Arkhan. Did I guess it right?!