Something happened around the era of Windows XP (was it XP?) that made this no longer possible. I'm not sure what it was specifically, but you can't just do that anymore. Kind of odd, IMO. It worked in Win 98, and it works in my 2 year old Macbook, with iTunes even pulling the track names for some games (Ys IV, for example).
So yeah, TurboRip. TurboRip is great.