I actually did like the last "club" (one that sunteam linked to) -- I was only a casual poster in that thread, but I enjoyed reading through everyone's thoughts.
But like some others with time constraints, I probably won't be touching Neo Metal Fantasy for some time due (even though I have it). It'd be cool to read how others are progressing through a game, though.
Hell, I started Tengai Makyo Ziria about a year ago(!) and still haven't finished it.