I got my games last week and everything is all good. Unfortunately, one (CD) game has a noticeable scratch but after testing didn't seem to affect gameplay. The manual is also stiff/waterlogged, but I'm VERY happy with the rest. In the future it would be better to list conditions more clearly, as well as ship in boxes (though mine arrived uncracked). But he is a nice guy and I appreciate that he offered them here first.
Thanks again and good luck with the rest of your sale!