The main reason being is because the music is just no where near as good . It's still decent and all, but it's just too "soft" for an Ys game now, I gotta go 80's style and bust on the TGCD .
Well, we actually solved that problem for ya, Keranu, if you didn't know. Deuce and I worked on getting all of Ryo's arrangements from the TGCD version to work on the Ys I & II Complete PC remake. (It's not "ETERNAL COMPLETE" btw; that was a mistake on my part because Falcom recycled the ETERNAL versions and didn't clean up some bitmaps that still had "ETERNAL" on them which should've been changed to "COMPLETE").
Anyway, here's the link:
http://www.classicgaming.com/ninjagaiden/ys/index.html?downloads.htmlThere are two rar archives for both I & II. You need to register with fileplanet to download them. Basically, you goto your YS1_WIN\WAVE\WAVE_44 folder, extract the rar there, and run the batch file. That'll decode the OGGs back to wave and set it all up. All I did was hack the looping files and Deuce made the OGGs the right length and did all the picking. His ReadMe shows you where each music file came from.
One of the more common complaints about the PC remakes of the Ys games is
that the music is not as blindingly awesome as the old TurboGrafx-CD mixes
were, so I decided to see what I could do alleviate that problem. The
Turbo/PC Engine mixes were well-funded, multi-synth layouts arranged by Ryo
Yonemitsu, whereas the default Windows mixes were just basic single-synth
MIDI files being run through a Roland sound module with a bit of production
to enrich the sound.
Where possible, I replaced the tracks with appropriate mixes from the
Turbo-CD, or from the Ys I Perfect Collection in the case of tracks that
had no CD-DA equivalent on the Turbo-CD, since that disc is also arranged
Ryo Yonemitsu.
There are a few tracks which are still using the original Windows versions,
as no suitable replacement could be found and/or Ryo Yonemitsu never made
any form of arrangement. Here is the track listing:
Example for Ys I:
Filename Trackname Source
------------------------------------------------------------------------
YS100_44.ogg Ys Eternal Opening Windows PC version
YS101_44.ogg Feena Ys I Perfect Collection
YS102_44.ogg Fountain of Love Ys I Perfect Collection
YS103_44.ogg The Syonin Ys I Perfect Collection
YS104_44.ogg Tears of Sylph Ys I Perfect Collection
YS105_44.ogg First Step Towards Wars TurboGrafx-CD
YS106_44.ogg Palace TurboGrafx-CD
YS107_44.ogg Holders of Power TurboGrafx-CD
YS108_44.ogg Palace of Destruction TurboGrafx-CD
YS109_44.ogg Beat of the Terror TurboGrafx-CD
YS110_44.ogg Tower of the Shadow of Death TurboGrafx-CD
YS111_44.ogg The Last Moment of the Dark TurboGrafx-CD
YS112_44.ogg Final Battle TurboGrafx-CD
YS113_44.ogg Rest in Peace TurboGrafx-CD
YS114_44.ogg The Morning Glow Ys I Perfect Collection
YS115_44.ogg See You Again TurboGrafx-CD
YS134_44.ogg Devil's Step Ys I Perfect Collection
YS135_44.ogg So Much for Today Ys I Perfect Collection
YS137_44.ogg Event Windows PC Version
YS138_44.ogg Departure Windows PC Version
YS139_44.ogg Open Your Heart Windows PC Version
YS140_44.ogg Dreaming Windows PC Version
YS141_44.ogg Tension Windows PC Version
YS142_44.ogg Chase of Shadow Windows PC Version
So if there was no TGCD Ryo Yonemitsu-arranged replacement, it stays with the PC version or he got it from one of the Falcom soundtracks like the Perfect Collection.
So yeah, that'll really make a difference, thus you'll be able to play the game the way it was meant to be played. Satisfaction guaranteed.
To bad i can't find a copy of the... pc version any more
Falcom did another print run of what's now coined as "Ys I & II Complete [Popular Edition]" just this past December. You can buy that from Himeya right now if you'd like to own a real copy, unless you know how to order from Falcom directly:
http://www.himeyashop.com/product_info.php/products_id/2892/That is what I have right now. It's a nice small box, with two DVDs in a movie-like DVD case. All they did is repackage the older separate XP releases from 2002.