Don't forget to tell everyone that you submerged it in liquid on a <40 degree day, which won't help, most likely.
Also, IIRC, that gray plastic is not even safe to mix with peroxide.
I submerged an SNES and it worked fine but it doesn't have that gray cap piece.
Liquid method works fine, dude.
You'd have had the same fate with the creamy method too. It just would have taken way longer for you to realize you screwed up...