I was thinking about this, due to the homebrew game Arkhan is putting out there.
For me, the last sealed game I opened, for the Turbo Grafx 16, was Super Star Soldier, in 2006 or 2007 or so.
I already had one, but someone I had been dealing with before, I knew had some sealed games. I was seeing what stock he had left, and asked about SSS, we agreed on $50. I opened it when it arrived, then sold off my more worn copy. I forget what was awkward about that one, the box may have been sunbleached, or crushed. Maybe the instructions were well-worn?
I know, "Collectard" is a thing around here now, but back then, I did stuff like that on occasion Things would even out, or I'd just end up spending an extra $10-$20 or so after I sold the other copy. Plus I liked opening the sealed SSS, because even back then, it wasn't too easy to come by. I think most would have left it sealed, so I at least saved that copy from entombment in shrink-wrap for who knows how long.
.