Neutopia 1 vs 2?

[lukester]

Thinking of playing one of these. Which one is best to start, and how do they compare to both zelda 1 and link to the past?

[roflmao]

Begin at the beginning and go on till you come to the end: then stop.
[/obsucre reference]

Also, the poll reads "Which one is best?" and what it sounds like you're asking is which one is best to start with?  They are both worth playing and if you intend on playing them both, play them in order.  I haven't finished the second one yet, but I've really enjoyed what I've played so far and I think the general conscientious is that the second one is marginally better. 

[spenoza]

If you are gonna play both, start with I. If you aren't interested in playing two similar titles, just play 2.

I definitely consider them more of a parallel evolution of the Zelda I model. They are more like Zelda I than L2tP. That doesn't mean they are simple, however. Character movement and interaction with the world doesn't feel quite as restricted as Zelda I, but the puzzles and dungeon designs aren't quite as clever. Also, the combat is more fast and furious. N2 is better than N1, but they are both VERY similar. N2 feels more like N1.5 in a lot of ways. Definitely more evolutionary than revolutionary.

[Dicer]

Play both, and cry at the end of 2...

[pulstar]

If you're going to play just one, play 2. If you're going to play both, start with 1. There isn't much in it, but 2 is better than 1.

[Necromancer]

Play 1 then 2.  Playing just one of them is not an option.

[Black Tiger]

For me it goes:

Neutopia
|
|
|
Neutopia 2
|
|
|
|
|
Zelda LttP

[lukester]

For me it goes:

Neutopia
|
|
|
Neutopia 2
|
|
|
|
|
Zelda LttP

Can you say why Black Tiger? I'm curious to know.

[seieienbu]

I like Neutopia 2 more than the first due to the ability to walk diagonally. 

Either way, I think Zelda 3 is a good deal better than both...

[Arkhan]

Playing Neutopia 2 before playing Neutopia 1 is dumb.

and, I am not sure if Neutopia is better than LTTP.   

Lttp is pretty Well put together, especially with the Dark World portions and the amount of variety in the game. 

and it has more depth to it.  Neutopia was clearly mimicking Zelda 1, and it destroys those. 

[richc]

Play 1 first and then 2.  1 blows the original LoZ away to me.  Better colors, controls, variety of music, detailed bosses.... its just a great game.  Neutopia 2 is also good, but there are a lot of spoilers if you play 2 first.  I'd make sure you have a lot of time before playing 2, its a monster of a game.

[toymachine78]

I don't think I can say that neutopia is better than LoZ. Zelda was original, and the size of the world blew my mind as a kid. Its classic gold, literally. Lol

My only gripe with neutopia is I think they got a little carried away with the hidden areas. Practically every section of the map has a hidden "room" on it. You get to the point where you expect to find one, which totally takes the fun and surprise out of it.

[Black Tiger]

For me it goes:

Neutopia
|
|
|
Neutopia 2
|
|
|
|
|
Zelda LttP

Can you say why Black Tiger? I'm curious to know.

I can't type much with my phone, so I won't ignite a flame war by daring to criticize LttP. So all I will say is that is how they rank for short and long term enjoyability. The only exception being that I haven't played Neutopia II enough times to judge it's long term enjoyability. LttP certainly burns out fast though, is light on art and the faux-NES graphic style wasn't pulled off well. Like most Zelda games I've played, what remains beneath is only neat to play through once until you forget most of it, but the tedious sections are still more frustrating than fun every time.

Neutopia was the first game to justify 16-bit console gaming for me and the boss battles are still exciting, while I find those in the other two games dull.

[toymachine78]

Agreed. The Bosses in Neutopia are boss!

[esteban]

Boss-some.
Bawsome.