This thread is awesome, and is another reason why I am so glad I started paying attention to the communities around the things I've enjoyed for so long. Hearing discussion about optimal audio compression in regards to reproducing a 'quality' sound warms my heart, and makes me incredibly envious of the pallet some are able to enjoy. I have some hardcore audiophile friends, and other friends with amazing artistic eyes, and their discussions about the quality degradation between formats always enthralls me. Threads like this make me realize how wrong I've done this so far. At times I feel like a guy who brought a box of wine to the tasting, but at least I'll know a bit more going forward. That being said, is there no gameplay video of this game available? It sounds so interesting, but I am having a hard time picturing it.
I'm glad Joe made the point about mp3 to wave format choice when ripping music from a cd game. It can always be downgraded for mp3 if needing to fit on a specific device, but it's probably best to create individual files at the highest quality possible. You can always downgrade a high quality file, it's a lot harder to upgrade