About a month ago I did the pennant race in World Class Baseball. I'm a sucker for most any baseball game, so I enjoyed it. Nothing special, just decent baseball action. I would play it again (or the subsequent power leagues on pce since there are different stadiums and slight differences).
I also really enjoy Sonic Spike. It's pretty great for a $15 sports game (bought it for that sealed on Amazon not too long ago). I would play it with some friends in my dorm last year and we had a lot of fun. They usually didn't like it at first and then grew to hate it slightly less. I got pretty good at it for awhile too. 2 on 2 with a multi tap provides some great action! I would recommended it to anyone with friends over. Give it a shot, tournament play could be fun with teams of two.
I've also enjoyed Hit the Ice from what I played briefly, it was fun and not slow like I remember TV Sports Hockey feeling when I played that.
I keep thinking I will try Sonic Spike to see if it holds up in 2015, but here I am, decades later, and I still haven't tried it out.
In my defense, I don't think I bought the game until a decade ago, but still.
I don't have ONE favorite TG-16 sports game, but I certainly have had fun with:
Power Golf (I enjoy all basic golf games, so this isn't saying much)
World Class Baseball (Ditto)
David Cup Tennis
I think we could put all the damn games in a poll and see the votes. Maybe we get 2-3 votes? Or would the results be obvious (World Sports Competition, j/k)?
Maybe we should POLL the top 2-3 games, eliminate them, and then create a new poll of the "Lesser-loved TG-16 Sports Games"
For example, I am not ashamed to admit that I had fun with TV SPORTS Football when it was released. A friend and I played it often. Of course, he quickly got so good that he could decimate the computer AI (no challenge at all). I think I only played a full season a handful of times. The same with TV SPORTS Hockey: 3-5 player games were fun, but I do not remember playing a full tournament more than a handful of times.
ALSO, WE HAVE TO POST AGENT_ORANGE's AWESOME POWER GOLF (or was it Jack Nicklaus) BLANCHING!