I always championed Samurai Ghost, since I felt it was under-appreciated...but I think it has gotten some deserved recognition.
I don't know if it is a Top 25, but it certainly is a game I find endearing (the defense/offense mechanics are more complex than folks realize...a running parry is possible, for example).
Not perfect, but it doesn't matter, since it is such a odd bird. The kind of quirky game I love.