I'm not sure about the refresh rates being different causing 1 frame drops. Since the refresh rates wouldn't be any different. The ATSC standard which is the HDTV standard supports multiple refresh rates, including the refresh rates from NTSC.
Does the EXT port provide the digital signals directly from the PPU?
That's a good question everything I've seen seems to point to it just sending the RGB and sync signal. The dude at db-elec might be able to answer that question since he makes a Grafx Booster for the Turbo Grafx (and I think core grafx) that allows you to get RGB, and SVideo out, and he does so by tapping into the ext port.
http://db-electronics.ca/product/dbgrafx-booster-ttp/
Their description here says digital:
The FAQ on the English site says that it’s missing the extra graphics when used for SuperGrafx games, which tells me that they aren’t interfacing with the muxed analog RGB.
GameTechUS got one of these to try out and I guess give feedback to the developer about.
Also HOLY SHIT 40,000 YEN! That's insanely expensive, buy a framemeister for less. It also works on a TG16, which makes sense since the pin out on that back port should probably be the same.
Said 35,000¥ ($316 USD) when I checked yesterday so it seems they’ve had s price drop. That would still be crazy expensive if we didn’t also factor that it now has an optical drive emulator (ODE) for CD-ROM^2 games. The Super SD System 3 is also around $300 for that functionality and it does not do digital video.
Way too expensive and no CD support is a show stopper for me.
I'm not sure what is the obsession with playing old games on a HDTV. I'm all about RGB and love image quality but I find myself using my CRT and s-video more than I do the xrgb mini on the 24" LCD. People can argue space but a decent 20" CRT does not take up that much space.
I would agree with your first statement except it looks like they intended to add an ODE all along.
Anyway, I completely disagree about RGB CRTs though, but not strictly in comparison to HDMI/DVI. It comes down to being able to connect/use your console with whatever set you encounter and being able to do so in the best quality the display supports.
RGB CRTs simply are not available in the USA where component and S-video monitors are plentiful (LCDs and CRTs). I always chuckle when Jason Rauch (GameTechUS) asks why anyone wants S-video or component... while sitting in front of his junk PVM that he has been unable to fix or replace for years (shifted purple).
Kevin Horton (Kevtris), who has done a PVM repair video of his own, even stopped by to look at it. He’s the perfect example of why component and S-video are better options for many people and yet he said it again in the recent video where he and Voultar critique Doujindance’s old Duo mod work.
Heck, with a collection of Wega Trinitron, HD Trinitron, and XBR SFP Trinitron TVs, I have some of the best consumer CRTs ever made and yet I still can’t properly utilize RGB. I probably can’t use this on those TVs either because their HDMI/DVI inputs are notoriously picky: PS3 HDMI output works in 480p, 720p, or 1080i, yet Hi-Def NES only works in 480p and UltraHDMI doesn’t work at all (so much for Kevtris and MarshallH enduring compatibility/compliance with that HDMI signal analyzer!). *sigh* Component and S-video work gloriously.
An OSSC will have the same issues with PCE/TG16 signals as it does for SNES signals. At least the UpperGrafx can buffer one frame to improve compatibility.
A 24” flat panel and a 20 CRT is not really a fair comparison because the sizes are only appropriate for personal use (these days). Perhaps I have a different perspective because my collection is shared with my twin brother, but neither of those are sized for playing 3p Secret of Mana or Mario Kart 64 Battle Mode in the living room when you have friends over. I can just disconnect my N64 and take it to the XBR LCD when friends arrive but I don’t have that freedom with RGB. Even with that scenario, I feel that a retro system worth playing deserves a spot in the living room. It’s literally what my living room home theater is for. I mean, screw television programming! I’d rather play some games on that XBR beast.
This has always been the case. In 2003 I returned a 30” $900 Samsung CRT HDTV and paid $2,300 for a different 30” CRT HDTV simply because 4:3 480p GameCube games were forced to stretch to 16:9 on the first one. I bought that HDTV specifically to play both 4:3 and 16:9 GCN and XBOX games in 480p. Heck, one of the first things I did was play around with Goldeneye 007’s anamorphic widescreen modes... using S-video. I don’t regret the purchase one bit as the only PVM/BVMs that compare have the exact same tube and this thing has served me well for gaming almost 15 years (finicky support for home brew digital output mods, not withstanding).
Currently working on new timing generator for the system to generate interlaced output
Awesome! Any updates on this?
GameTechUS got one of these to try out and I guess give feedback to the developer about.
Also HOLY SHIT 40,000 YEN! That's insanely expensive, buy a framemeister for less. It also works on a TG16, which makes sense since the pin out on that back port should probably be the same.
OK, in light of the new competing PCE Super SD System 3 product, I was reminded of this Japanese DVI/HDMI supporting one.
Notes:
* http://www.upergrafx.com
* https://twitter.com/upergrafx
* It's called Uper Grafx 720p Booster.
* Output port is DVI, so you need a DVI to HDMI cable, audio is included so you don't need separate RCA connections.
* Pricing according to GameTechUS was hovering at $368 or 40,000 YEN, not good...
* From looking at the Japanese website with Google Translate, it appears CD image support has been added. It needs images made with CD Manipulator. http://www.upergrafx.com/cdrom2_setup_ja
* There's some debate if it taps a digital signal or does a good job of encoding the analog RGB back to digital before tripling the resolution from 240p to 720p. Better be all digital for the kind of money you're looking at! States it's full digital on their Twitter. Tough call on this one, but definitely has potential. I just want the board that triples the resolution and encodes to DVI/HDMI like what GameTech is talking about. I hope further progress is made on it.
If that 35,000¥, $316 USD price I see is right, it seems that there has been a price drop.
No question about the video interface though: It’s definitely digital. See the description here:
Also, their English FAQ says that SuperGrafx games are missing their extra graphics, which would not happen if they were simply converting analog RGB.