The Xanadu English dub-project is getting close to liftoff.
Excellent!!!
However Elmer, if the subs insertion on SGX/SCD combo you evoked in another thread is doable without not much work, it would be more than awesome!!!
The advantage of a potential SGX dub, is that there's all this extra RAM, extra VRAM, and extra sprites available that the game knows nothing about, and so won't interfere with.
But it would still be a major hack to get it working in the game.
The biggest issue is that each of the visual sequences uses 2 different methods for controlling the overall sequence timing, and there's only one of those that I could sensibly hack into. That could make the subtitle timing a bit iffy, and bad subtitles that drifted off-sync would be terrible.
And anyway, apart from ashrion, most folks (IMHO) would prefer to have an English dub if it's done well, and I have total faith that SamIAm will do a great job of it.
You will have two choices:
1. Use the dub.
2. Print out the script and read it while you play.
Yep, that's always been SamIAm's goal. If you don't want to hear English voices in the game, then you'll just be able to install the English text patch without the dub.
Subtitles are impossible on this hardware and with these two games. There are no resources to do it with.
That's exactly the problem from my POV ... where is the memory supposed to come from for the graphics for the subtitles, and how are they going to be displayed without breaking Falcom's original timings for the cutscenes???
I can see how it *might* be possible with the extra hardware of the SuperGrafx, but I really have trouble believing that it's possible on the base PCE.
I would much rather do subtitles myself. It is much easier for me. However, I want people to be able to play the games without using a paper script.
Honestly, I'd probably prefer subtitles, too. That's how I prefer to watch most foreign movies, unless the dubbing is done exceptionally well (like Cowboy Bebop).
I'll do a little more research, but I really don't hold out much hope.