The thing is, their whole premise is supposed to be that any video game related tattoo sucks, but these are supposed to be the most hideous.
But then they throw in some of the least hideous/best ones around and say that they're awful simply because they identify so well as being video game related and as such, are lame and repugnant.
Not only does the list seem to contradict itself, but the site also comes off as anti-"gaming" and it's called "gamerhelp.com: gamers helping gamers".