Saw this at the sneak preview the night before it opened in my town, (Thursday, May 7, 2009) with my Dad. We're both casual Star Trek fans, and I thought the movie was pretty good!
I loved the mixture of freshness and familiarity, and I thought the casting and writing was excellent.
My only complaint was that it felt more like Star Wars than Star Trek at times. But besides that, I was completely enthralled. I loved the cast, I thought they did a wonderful job of channeling the original cast.
One of my favorite moments was the skydive onto the drill early in the movie. When I saw that redshirt going with them, I smiled. I KNEW what would happen, and I was not disappointed. In fact, I think that had to be the most spectacular redshirt death I've ever seen.
I loved the humor, the whole audience erupted with laughter throughout the movie, and my favorite joke has to be when Kirk meets Old Spock. What Kirk says has to be one of the most hilariously ironic moments in Star Trek history.
I liked seeing Kirk cheating the Kobiyashi Maru, but I kept wondering throughout the scenes at the academy when we would meet Fennigan! (See Shore Leave from the Orrignal Series).
So, overall, the movie, despite a few small disappointments, was great. My Dad liked it too, comparing it to Wrath of Khan, his (and many Trekkies') favorite Star Trek movie.
I will definitely be buying this when it comes out on Bluray! (I'm trying to save for a PS3)