i'm looking to make better use out of my arcade card.
i've heard the ACD Strider is pretty crappy, is that true? how is Art of fighting, mad stalker and Kabuki itouryodan? any other suggestions as far as the SCD/ACD games go?
(i have Fatal fury special, FF2, World heroes 2 and Brandish and i'm not about to shell out $450 or more for sapphire.)
Strider isn't as crappy as it's made out to be, but it would be substandard as a Super CD game. It doesn't have independant scrolling bg's and there is more flicker than the Genesis 'version'. However, it does use mostly the original arcade graphics as a basis where as the Genesis version is totally from scratch. So it's got a lot more detail in the backgrounds, but it wasn't touched up much. If you really like Strider(I'm not a big fan), its still the same game, but doesn't take advantage of the Arcade Card in any way.
The Neo Geo ports are all the best of the 16-bit generation. If you like any of the originals or fighting games in general, you'll be love them. If you just want a showcase for the Arcade card and/or the PCE, they'll blow you away(which you must know). Art Of Fighting is as close to the original as any of the other ports and the sprites are huge and super clean. Other than transitional scaling, its as close as you could hope for.
Kabuki Itouryoden is the best ACD game there is. The characters are super animated and detailed, it has nice SF-style gameplay and beautiful BGs. It has huge character select art on par with the Capcom VS games.
Sapphire isn't worth buying, but is worth playing as an iso/cdr.
People seem really impressed by Mad Stalker, I haven't played it enough to be. It looked like a Super CD to me during the 1st level.
I haven't been able to tell the difference in any hybrid games, ACD/SCD nor CD2/SCD. They don't make use of the Arcade Card in any noticible way. Popful Mail is a fun game regardless. You can make it through with zero japanese knowledge using my walkthrough on GameFAQs.
You already have a couple of the best ACDs, I'd just recommend holding out for super cheap copies of Itouryoden and Art Of Fighting.
Unfortunately, there's not much else out there. At least there are a handful of titles that did justify the card.