Even though I'm "anti-collector" (or whatever) and I don't do US versions of PCE games, I still don't get all the hate from the green one.
I think the idea of documenting inserts (real inserts, like maps, not useless shit like reply cards and ads for Turbo merch that are more or less the same from game to game) is a very good one. The best way to get this capability into the hands of the common user though, IMO, is to ask the guys at PCEDaisakusen to add some sort of feature to accommodate it. That site is f*cking awesome, IMO, and I'm sure they would be interesting in adding some extra check boxes or something to their database. I suggested the "this game completed" thing and they added it in a few days. PCE games came with even more free crap than US ones, and I still wonder about some of it. Did all copies of Yuna 2 come with that cool foil sticker, or just the first run? People ask about Tengai 1 once in a while. Exactly what came with each version, etc. What RPGs came with maps and charts, that kind of thing.
[EDIT] I spoke/wrote too soon. Now that I've actually looked at the site, and I'm remembering who RoyVegas actually is (high rolling Fantasy Island guest star, multiple copies of overpriced games that have never been played, etc) I can see where Emerald Rocker was coming from. This pretty much does look like a "brag" site, and while the argument that people would like to know what exactly comes with every game is totally valid, I think the best way to make that info usable is, as I said, to work with PCED to work it into their site which already catalogs almost everything valid already and is much more useful in general. Also, it doesn't make we want to puke my f*cking guts out, even though the guys that run that site have collections just as ridiculous, so that's something there. Also, when Roy eventually sells off his collection Crazy Dion style (as nearly all megacollectors eventually do) what will become of the site? I think PCED is here to stay...or at least as "here to stay" as anything on the internet can be.